5 Puakukui Pl 5-2, Lahaina, 96761

Residential - Condominium For Sale in Puamana

$1,234,567

3Beds
3Baths
1,550Sqft
30Acres
1968Built
23DOM
MLS® #: 408442
Active, 23 Days on Market

Nestled just a 30-second walk from the beach, surf breaks, and Puamana’s beautifully renovated oceanfront pool, this rare opportunity offers the chance to create a brand-new coastal retreat within Puamana, one of West Maui’s most cherished oceanfront communities. The property previously hosted a legal 3-bedroom, 3-bath vacation-rental townhome, and plans have been submitted to rebuild the residence with the same 3BD/3BA configuration—preserving its valuable legal short-term rental status. The Association anticipates County permit approvals shortly and plans to move forward with construction of the new exterior shell, which is included in the purchase price. Once the shell is completed by the Association, the buyer will complete the interior from the studs in, allowing full freedom to customize finishes, design details, and personal style. A local Puamana contractor estimates interior build-out costs at approximately $250–$300 per square foot, plus furnishings. The submitted plans feature an open-concept living and dining area, a ground-floor bedroom and bath, and two upstairs en-suite bedrooms—designed for comfort, privacy, and effortless island living. This corner-oriented location enjoys an ocean-view direction and close proximity to the community’s pools, beach access, and surf breaks, embodying the relaxed ocean lifestyle Puamana is known for. Puamana offers a rare blend of privacy and resort-style amenities, including two swimming pools (one oceanfront), tennis and pickleball courts, a children’s playground, three surf breaks, lush tropical gardens, and a seasonal golden sand beach. Residents enjoy a peaceful oceanfront setting away from large resort crowds, while remaining conveniently close to the world-class golf, dining, shopping, and resort amenities of Kaanapali and Kapalua. As Puamana thoughtfully rebuilds following the August 2023 fires, this offering represents a unique moment in time: the opportunity to secure a prime location, benefit from a brand-new exterior structure, and create a personalized interior vision within an established, iconic oceanfront community. An exceptional opportunity to invest in the next chapter of Puamana and build a future home that reflects the very best of Maui living. The seller may consider seller financing, providing an added layer of flexibility in today’s evolving market.

Essential Information

MLS® #: 408442
Price: $1,234,567
Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 3.00
Square Footage: 1,550
Acres: 30.00
Year Built: 1968
Type: Residential
Sub-Type: Condominium
Land Tenure: Fee Simple
Status: Active

Community Information

Address: 5 Puakukui Pl 5-2
Area: Lahaina
Subdivision: Puamana
Building Name: Puamana
City: Lahaina
State: HI
Zip Code: 96761

Amenities

Utilities: Phone Connected, Cable Connected
View: Ocean
Waterfront: Across Street from Ocean
Has Pool: Yes
Pool: In Ground

Exterior

Exterior Features: Tennis Court(s), Barbecue

Additional Information

Listed By: Mark A Marchello Inc
Date Listed: January 16th, 2026
Days on Market: 23
Zoning: Interim
Monthly Maintenance Fees: $779.00
Division: 2
Zone: 4
Section: 6
Plat: 031

Financials

$/SqFt: $796

Properties for Sale Similar to 5 Puakukui Pl 5-2, Lahaina, HI

Kaanapali Shores #727 – Enjoy Exceptional Ocean...

NEW Photo of Listing #408688

$1,300,000 Active Fee Simple

  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 10.1 Acres
  • 964 ft²

Residential

3445 Lower Honoapiilani Rd 727, Kaanapali, HI

MLS® #408688

Listed By: Keller Williams Realty Maui-L
Office Contact: Cell: 808-870-2525

Kaanapali Shores #727 – Enjoy Exceptional Ocean Views From This Well-appointed 7th-floor, Two-bedroom, Two-bath Residence At Kaanapali Shores, Overlooking The Beautifully Landscaped Courtyard And Out Toward The Pacific. The Upgraded Kitchen Features Granite...

Just Steps From World-famous Kaanapali Beach, W...

Photo of Listing #407705

$1,350,000 Active Fee Simple

  • 1 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 6.67 Acres
  • 901 ft²

Residential

2481 Kaanapali Pkwy 111, Kaanapali, HI

MLS® #407705

Listed By: Monte D Fitts REALTOR

Just Steps From World-famous Kaanapali Beach, Whaler 111 Is A Ground-floor 1-bedroom, 2-bath Condo With An Ideal Location As A Tropical Oasis That Captures The Essence Of Maui’s Resort Lifestyle. Lush Tropical Landscaping With A Waterfeature, Koi Pond And F...

You Simply Must Come By And Look At This Fabulo...

NEW Photo of Listing #408634

$1,295,000 Active Fee Simple

  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 37.9 Acres
  • 1,269 ft²

Residential

50 Puu Anoano St 1707, Kaanapali, HI

MLS® #408634

Listed By: Coldwell Banker Island Prop-KP
Office Contact: Cell: 808-276-6061

You Simply Must Come By And Look At This Fabulous Ground Floor Unit. Prepare Yourself To Be Happy From The Moment You Walk Through The Front Door If This Wonderful Home. The Seller Recently Replaced The Shower In The Guest Bath, And Spa Tub In The Main Bath...

This information is believed to be accurate. It has been provided by sources other than the Realtors Assoc. of Maui and should not be relied upon without independent verification.


You should conduct your own investigation and consult with appropriate professionals to determine the accuracy of the information provided and to answer any questions concerning the property and structures located thereon.


Featured properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting this brochure. Copyright, 1995-2015, REALTORS® Association of Maui, Inc. All Rights Reserved.